Talk:Gaily Forward Alchemy

An explanation of the underlying philosophy behind the Voltron Tournament.

TL;DR

Amtgard is a LARP; and this MTG tournament is for LARPers! It is designed for the Timmies, Vorthosi and the occasional Johnny in our LARP community. It is for roleplayers and flurbs and folks who want a different experience than what they'll find at their typical Local Game Store(LGS)'s tourney scene.

Minimalism

This game's scoring system is designed to cultivate a diverse metagame that hopefully never devolves into a "combostax"-heavy meta (more on that later).

Our scoring system tries to achieve the most good, using absolutely minimal intervention:

• There is no banned list beyond the official one.
• There are no actual changes to the game rules of Magic: The Gathering.
• The rules do not utilize negative reinforcement.

Instead, the Voltron tourney uses only positive reinforcement to reward the behavior it wants to see:

• Look-the-part trinkets encourage costuming, which fosters a relaxed, if silly atmosphere.
• Look-the-part trinkets incentivize players not to scoop, without actually making a game-rule against scooping.
• The kill-based scoring system rewards non cEDH strategies (not-being-rewarded isn't the same thing as being punished).
• The one-hour time limit incentivizes faster gameplay; discouraging slower control decks or stax decks because such a deck would deny their owners the opportunity to score (as well as denying others that same opportunity).

 "cEDH"  = competitive EDH (more info)

ok but why though?

Because it's fun, heterodox, and unique.

I've been an EDH player since the 2000s - long before this fan-made format was officially recognized by WoTC. I've played in numerous tournaments, large and smol.

In my experience - When an LGS creates a new EDH tournament scene: for a time, there may be a healthy and interesting level of deck biodiversity. But from what I've observed: on a long-enough timescale, all competitive metas will eventually devolve into ComboStax.

Another stark reality I've observed: Most MTG players don't play in tournaments for this very reason. Combo/Stax decks aren't particularly fun to play against, unless you yourself also run one of the few deck archetypes that can deal with it (with combostax being arguably the most reliable way to counter other combostax decks). Combostax's ichor spreads through a metagame like a Permeating Mass. And that's so boring.

Note: If someone enjoys playing cEDH and/or combostax: that's fine! This is not a personal attack. There are so many LGSs to choose from, where that person can enjoy themselves. Such playstyles are simply not the target audience of this tournament.

From Hiraeth to Saudade...

As you may know, the fan-made format "Elder Dragon Highlander" was not originally intended to be a competitive format. While winning is technically always the goal of any MTG game, EDH was different - the idea of "cEDH" would have been considered a cringeworthy anachronism. Years later, EDH was officially recognized by Wizards of the Coast/Hasbro in 2010/2011-ish, and the name was changed from "Elder Dragon Highlander" to "Commander". Since then, the format has changed a lot. In some ways, it has become an antonym of it's former self.

I invite you to join me for a walk backwards in time to the early days of the EDH format, and experience an altogether different style of gameplay.

Above all, I hope you all enjoy yourselves at this strange and silly tournament.

:)